| PAC Player of the Year |
Year |
| Nick Miller |
2022 |
| Conference Offensive Players of the Year |
Year |
| Lucas Cross |
2023 |
| Leo Herrmann |
2017 |
| Leo Herrmann |
2016 |
| Leo Herrmann |
2015 |
| PAC Defensive Player of the Year |
Year |
| Ryan Miller |
2024 |
| Conference Newcomer of the Year |
Year |
| Jonathan Schriner |
2021 |
| Leo Herrmann |
2014 |
| Leonel Lacayo |
2010 |
| PAC Coach of the Year |
Year |
| Brent Ridenour |
2024 |
Franciscan University Men's Soccer All-Conference Selections
2025: First Team: Aidan Henninger (D/Sr.), Lucas Cross (F/Sr.); Second Team: Zachary Muldoon (D/Sr.), Augustine Rubino (M/Sr.); Honorable Mention: Anthony Venditti (M/Jr.), Andrew Goduti (F/Fr.)
2024: First Team: Ryan Miller (M/Sr.), Lucas Cross (F/Jr.), Joseph St. George (D/Sr.); Second Team: Julien Freeman (F/Jr.), Zachary Muldoon (D/Jr.), Aiden Miller (GK/So.); Honorable Mention: Jonathan Schriner (F/Sr.), Augustine Rubino (M/Jr.)
2023: First Team: Lucas Cross (F/So.), Ryan Miller (M/Jr.), Joseph St. George (D/Jr.); Second Team: Aidan Henninger (D/So.), Augustine Rubino (M/So.); Honorable Mention: Jonathan Schriner (F/Jr.)
2022: First Team: Nick Miller (M/Gr.), Jonathan Schriner (F/So.); Second Team: Liam Nagle (D/Gr.), Chris St. George (D/Gr.), Augustine Rubino (F/Fr.); Honorable Mention: Jax Mautone (G/Gr.), Ryan Miller (M/So.), Joseph St. George (D/So.)
2021: First Team: Sebastian Koehler (F/Gr.), Nick Miller (M/Gr.); Second Team: Liam Nagle (D/Sr.), Jonathan Schriner (F/Fr.); Honorable Mention: Jax Mautone (GK/Jr.), Ryan Miller (M/Fr.), Joseph St. George (D/Fr.)
2020-21: First Team: Sebastian Koehler (F/Sr.), Nick Miller (M/Jr.); Second Team: Mikey Irvin (F/Jr.)
2019: First Team: Nick Miller (M/So.); Second Team: Sebastian Koehler (F/Jr.), JP Bobak (F/Jr.), Joseph Leonardi (D/Jr.); Third Team: Ian Baldau (M/Sr.), Chip Dougherty (D,Sr.), Brian Gaughan (GK,Jr.)
2018: Second Team: JP Bobak (M/So.); Third Team: Leo James (D/Sr.)
2017: First Team: Leo Herrmann (M/Sr.); Second Team: JP Bobak (M/Fr.); Third Team: Tom Dosedel (GK/Sr.), Leo James (D/Jr.)
2016: First Team: Leo Herrmann (M/Jr.); Second Team: Tom Dosedel (GK/Jr.), Joe Francis (M/Sr.), Dom Vander Woude (D/Jr.); Third Team: Joe Duran (M/Sr.)
2015: First Team: Leo Herrmann (M/So.); Third Team: Joe Duran (M/Jr.), John Imbimbo (M/Sr.)
2014: First Team: Leo Herrmann (M/Fr.); Third Team: Joe Duran (M/So.), John Imbimbo (M/Jr.)
2013: Third Team: Joe Duran (M/Fr.), John Imbimbo (M/So.)
2011: Third Team: Tommy Allen
2010: Second Team: Leonel Lacayo (M/Fr.); Third Team: James Kozlowski
2009: First Team: Steve Duran (M/Sr.); Second Team: Christian Bobak (M/Sr.); Third Team: Kyle Langon
2008: First Team: Steve Duran (M/Jr.)
Four-Time All-Conference
Joe Duran - 2013-16
Leo Herrmann - 2014-17
Nick Miller 2018-22
Jonathan Schriner - 2021-24
Joseph St. George - 2021-24
Ryan Miller - 2021-24
Augustine Rubino 2022-25
Three-Time All-Conference
Sebastian Koehler 2019-21
JP Bobak - 2017-19
John Imbimbo - 2013-15
Lucas Cross 2022-25
Two-Time All-Conference
Tom Dosedel - 2016-17
Steve Duran - 2008-09
Leo James - 2017-18
Liam Nagle - 2018-22
Jax Mautone - 2019-22
Aidan Henninger - 2022-25
Zachary Muldoon - 2022-25
OCSA Honors
2024: First Team: Lucas Cross (F/Jr.); Second Team: Ryan Miller (M/Sr.); Third Team: Aiden Miler (GK/So.), Julien Freeman (F/Jr.)
2023: Second Team: Lucas Cross (F/So.)
2022: First Team: Nick Miller (M/Gr.); Second Team: Jonathan Schriner (F/So.); Third Team: Liam Nagle (D/Gr.); Academic First Team: Nick Miller (M/Gr.), Chris St. George (D/Gr.)
2021: Third Team: Nick Miller (M/Sr.), Sebastian Koehler (F/Gr.); Academic First Team: Sebastian Koehler (F/Gr.)
2017: First Team: Leo Herrman (M/Sr.)
2016: First Team : Leo Herrmann (M/Jr.)
ECAC Honors
| ECAC Offensive Player of the Year |
Year |
| Lucas Cross |
2023 |
| ECAC Defensive Player of the Year |
Year |
| Ryan Miller |
2024 |
| ECAC Rookie of the Year |
Year |
| Leo Herrmann |
2014 |
All-ECAC Selections
2024: First Team: Lucas Cross (F/Jr.), RyanMiller (M/Sr.)
2023: First Team: Lucas Cross (F/So.), Ryan Miller (M/Jr.), Joseph St. George (D/Jr.)
2017:
First Team: Leo Herrmann (M/Sr.)
2016:
First Team: Leo Herrmann (M/Jr.)
2014:
First Team: Leo Herrmann (M/Fr.)
NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches Honors
All-America Selections
2017: Third Team: Leo Herrmann (M/Sr.)
All-Region Selections
2024: Second Team: Lucas Cross (F/Jr.);
Third Team: Aiden Miller (GK/So.)
2023: Second Team: Lucas Cross (F/So.)
2022: Second Team: Nick Miller (M/Gr.)
2021: Third Team: Nick Miller (M/Sr.)
2017: First Team: Leo Herrmann (M/Sr.)
2016: Second Team: Leo Herrmann (M/Jr.)
2015: Third Team: Leo Herrmann (M/So.)
